“This might not be the perfect bill. This may not go as far as people want . . . But we need to do something!”
This sounds suspiciously like the infamous Obamacare justification line (“once you pass the bill, you’ll know what’s in it”). Recall that Obamacare that was passed solely by Democrats, who at that time felt like “something needed to be done,” and so they rushed and passed the significantly flawed A.C.A. This is not the A.C.A. all over again, but it is going to be passed by predominately, if not solely, California Democrats. I am talking here about California Senate Bill 10, that just passed out of the state Assembly and is headed to the state Senate for final approval.
For those not in the know, California Senate Bill 10 is California’s version of bail reform.
The proponents of SB10 say that it is not just about bail — the refundable cash or property that a defendant traditionally deposited with the court as a guarantee that he or she would show up for trial, or the unrefundable percentage that modern-day defendants pay to bail agents for putting up the full amount. They proclaim that it is more about justice between arrest and trial, and the time-honored American premise that even a person accused of a serious crime is to be treated as innocent until proven guilty.
The basic conundrum is that the rich can always post bail, while the poor often cannot, and the consequences of not being able to post bail are much more dramatic for the poor whose lives are dramatically effected if they need to stay in jail until their trial. They lose their jobs if they do not show up, and they often lose their home because they cannot pay the rent or the mortgage. This occurs whether or not they are ultimately found guilty or innocent. The proponents of SB 10 say that the presumption of innocence should translate into a presumption that people who are arrested and arraigned should then be set free to return to their homes, families and jobs and be in the best position to prepare their defense.
Senate Bill 10 will mandate the use of risk assessments in pretrial release decisions. In theory these assessments can allow for more defendants to be released pretrial while maintaining public safety. More specifically these risk assessments are questionnaires that gather information about a defendant’s criminal and/or social history and use this information to output a risk score. Pretrial risk assessments intend to predict what a defendant would do if released before their trial: specifically, whether they will fail to appear in court and whether they are a risk to public safety.
My initial reaction to SB10 was that it was a bad bill, and it would just return criminals to the streets. However after I thought about it for awhile, I thought that the concept was good, but the trick would be putting that concept into practice.
My opinion was tempered by the fact that the A.C.L.U. was for SB10. However here in the last few days, because of amendments, the A.C.L.U. changed its opinion, and came out against it . . . now I am even more sure that SB10 is a good idea.
If it passes and is signed by the governor, there are few things that almost certainly will occur. Something heinous will be done by someone who passed the pretrial risk assessment, and was released without bail prior to his/her trial. Likewise certain judges will be castigated because they are not releasing a high enough percentage of those who appear before them with marginal pretrial risk assessments.
Oftentimes with bills written and moved through the system in haste, there are flaws, and SB10 has certainly been pushed through the legislature with alarming alacrity. I would propose that such a radical departure (no bail) from long established norms (bail for everyone charged) is not wise. My suggestion would be to pass SB10, but with a trial period of two or three years during which everyone will be able to evaluate if SB10 is working, or if its flaws far outweigh its benefits. If in fact after two or three years, it turns out to be all that it is advertised to be, then it could be made permanent.
lipitor 40mg for sale order atorvastatin pills buy atorvastatin 20mg
order generic cipro 500mg – order ciprofloxacin 1000mg generic augmentin 375mg price
cipro 500mg us – augmentin 375mg brand augmentin 625mg uk
buy metronidazole online – azithromycin 250mg for sale buy azithromycin pill
cost ciprofloxacin – tindamax medication order erythromycin 500mg for sale
order valtrex 1000mg online cheap – buy valacyclovir no prescription acyclovir online buy
ivermectin 6 mg tablet – ceftin buy online order tetracycline
flagyl cheap – buy amoxil tablets generic azithromycin 250mg
ampicillin antibiotic online amoxicillin pills buy amoxicillin generic
buy furosemide 40mg for sale – buy coumadin 5mg generic capoten 25 mg ca
order generic metformin 500mg – buy cefadroxil 250mg order lincocin 500 mg online cheap
buy zidovudine 300mg generic – glycomet online allopurinol cheap
buy clozapine 100mg generic – amaryl over the counter generic famotidine 20mg
order quetiapine 50mg online – effexor pills order eskalith online
clomipramine 25mg pill – buy generic doxepin 75mg cheap doxepin 75mg
buy generic hydroxyzine 10mg – buy hydroxyzine online endep 25mg us
buy clavulanate pills for sale – linezolid online baycip us
purchase amoxil sale – order keflex 125mg without prescription baycip pill
cleocin 300mg generic – oxytetracycline 250mg pills buy chloramphenicol sale
azithromycin 500mg cost – ofloxacin 400mg brand buy generic ciplox over the counter
ivermectin 3 mg – levofloxacin for sale purchase cefaclor
buy albuterol tablets – promethazine us theophylline 400 mg over the counter
clarinex for sale – buy beclomethasone medication albuterol inhalator price
buy oral methylprednisolone – order singulair generic azelastine 10ml cheap
pill glyburide – glucotrol 10mg cost order forxiga 10 mg without prescription
repaglinide 1mg uk – repaglinide 2mg usa buy jardiance 25mg online
glycomet 500mg tablet – januvia 100mg pill buy acarbose 50mg without prescription
order generic terbinafine – grifulvin v uk cheap grifulvin v
semaglutide 14mg generic – where to buy semaglutide without a prescription DDAVP generic
ketoconazole oral – butenafine cheap itraconazole sale
famvir price – order valaciclovir 500mg pills brand valaciclovir 500mg
order lanoxin 250 mg pill – buy verapamil without a prescription furosemide 100mg ca
where can i buy microzide – how to get plendil without a prescription how to buy bisoprolol
buy metoprolol generic – cozaar 50mg drug order nifedipine 10mg generic
buy nitroglycerin sale – buy catapres without a prescription valsartan 80mg cheap
simvastatin preparation – atorvastatin empty lipitor pin
rosuvastatin online shutter – ezetimibe fill caduet pills monsieur
buy viagra professional narrow – viagra gold online scramble levitra oral jelly ancient
dapoxetine prisoner – sildigra country cialis with dapoxetine stock
cenforce husband – zenegra pills enter brand viagra council
brand cialis friendship – viagra soft tabs mist penisole scholar
cialis soft tabs online description – levitra soft online ourself viagra oral jelly slide
brand cialis england – forzest still penisole nay
cialis soft tabs pills eater – viagra oral jelly online proof viagra oral jelly online fear