“Mucosal Immunity” was a term that I was unfamiliar with until just recently. I know what the words mean, but was not attuned as to how ‘mucosal immunity,’ was relevant to Covid infections, reinfections, and vaccinations.
In a similar vein the recent data out of Israel was a bit perplexing until I decided to try to apply a dose of common sense, and this in combination with my newfound knowledge concerning ‘mucosal immunity’ proved to be useful.
To recap, in Israel the delta variant has caused a new spike in Covid infections. 40% of these new infections were in individuals who had been previously vaccinated, whereas less than 1% (72/7400) were in individuals who had had a prior documented Covid infection. The obvious implication from these numbers is that a prior infection with Covid is markedly more protective than vaccination in terms of contracting a reinfection.
The following is from a recent op-ed in the WSJ by Dr. Michael Segal:
“‘Mucosal immunity’ provides the first line of defense by protecting the nose and mouth, and by doing so also reduces spread to others. The mucous membranes secrete a particular form of antibodies of the Immunoglobulin A type, or IgA.
In contrast, ‘Internal immunity’ protects the inside of the body, including the lungs. This occurs by release of antibodies of the Immunoglobulin G type, or IgG, into the blood and production of T-cells. Vaccines injected into our muscles are highly effective at stimulating internal immunity. This largely protects vaccinated people from being overwhelmed by the coronavirus.”
Dr. Segal continues:
But vaccines injected into our muscles—including all the approved inoculations against Covid—are largely ineffective at stimulating the secretion of IgA into our noses that occurs after actual infection with a virus. As a result, vaccinated people can contract a Covid-19 infection confined to the mucous membranes. They may get the sniffles but can spread the virus to others even if they are asymptomatic.”
The other finding out of Israel is that the effectiveness of the Pfizer vaccine is waning over time, and thus Israel is using boosters to increase the protection afforded by vaccines. Similarly, boosters are now being advised for some individuals, and it will only be a matter of time before all vaccinated individuals will be advised to get a booster. And in the future will these boosters also lose their effectiveness over time requiring boosters for the original booster? Etc, ad infinitum.
So here’s my question:
If the effectiveness of vaccines is waning over time, and the protection from reinfection is very very high among those with a documented Covid infection, does it not make sense to allow those with a minuscule risk from Covid to actually get the infection? Here I am specifically referring to grade school children (who are not eligible for a vaccine), and high school students whose risk from Covid is quite low, albeit not zero. In fact I would extend this to college students. If masks, etc. actually work, would it be better to not impose mask mandates on these groups?
To summarize, I sent the following letter to the editor to the Wall Street Journal:
“If, as was stated in Dr. Segal’s op-Ed on 8/16, lasting mucosal (IgA) immunity is only achievable through an actual Covid infection, why are continued mask wearing and social distancing being advised for young children? Since young children tolerate Covid quite well, why wouldn’t logic dictate that they not be protected with masks, etc. in schools, thus allowing them to develop lasting IgA mucosal immunity on their own?”
8/23/21
buy atorvastatin 20mg order atorvastatin 10mg without prescription generic atorvastatin 40mg
cipro 1000mg cost – augmentin 625mg pills amoxiclav medication
buy generic ciprofloxacin for sale – buy clavulanate without prescription augmentin over the counter
flagyl 200mg sale – order cleocin 150mg generic order generic zithromax 250mg
buy ciprofloxacin 500 mg online – order chloramphenicol purchase erythromycin for sale
order valacyclovir 500mg online – diltiazem buy online purchase acyclovir for sale
ivermectin 12mg otc – order cefuroxime generic order tetracycline 250mg for sale
order metronidazole 200mg for sale – terramycin where to buy azithromycin 250mg for sale
ampicillin brand buy cheap generic acillin order amoxicillin for sale
lasix 100mg cheap – order furosemide 40mg online buy cheap capoten
order glucophage 500mg sale – purchase ciprofloxacin sale order lincomycin 500mg sale
retrovir 300 mg pills – roxithromycin tubes order allopurinol for sale
clozapine cost – order accupril for sale oral pepcid
order quetiapine 50mg online cheap – purchase seroquel for sale eskalith price
buy anafranil tablets – buy citalopram 40mg online sinequan canada
atarax over the counter – buy fluoxetine 40mg without prescription endep without prescription
amoxil where to buy – buy cheap generic duricef cipro 500mg us
clavulanate generic – linezolid 600 mg usa buy ciprofloxacin paypal
order cleocin 150mg generic – cheap chloramphenicol for sale cheap chloramphenicol pills
zithromax over the counter – ciprofloxacin cheap ciplox 500 mg without prescription
ivermectin for sale – buy cefaclor pills cefaclor 250mg usa
ventolin brand – purchase seroflo generic buy cheap generic theophylline
clarinex 5mg pills – order beclomethasone strongest over the counter antihistamine
methylprednisolone 4mg otc – methylprednisolone 4 mg over the counter buy astelin 10 ml generic
order micronase 2.5mg online cheap – actos 30mg cheap dapagliflozin buy online
order glucophage 1000mg – glycomet oral order precose for sale
buy generic terbinafine online – generic lamisil purchase grifulvin v sale
order rybelsus 14 mg generic – DDAVP drug desmopressin us
oral ketoconazole 200mg – mentax usa buy sporanox paypal
buy famciclovir no prescription – valaciclovir brand order valaciclovir pill
digoxin for sale – labetalol 100 mg tablet order lasix without prescription
hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg cheap – buy bisoprolol without prescription zebeta 10mg for sale
purchase lopressor pills – olmesartan 20mg uk nifedipine cost
where can i buy nitroglycerin – valsartan 80mg uk valsartan 80mg tablet
crestor online listen – rosuvastatin online race caduet pills glance
how to buy simvastatin – gemfibrozil opposite lipitor tin
buy viagra professional rank – buy viagra professional ireland levitra oral jelly online feature
priligy kiss – fildena people cialis with dapoxetine half
cenforce online let – cenforce account brand viagra den
brand cialis though – alprostadil powerful penisole foolish
cialis soft tabs bedroom – caverta pills member viagra oral jelly online spring
brand cialis minister – tadora oh penisole carpet
cialis soft tabs pills confusion – cialis oral jelly pills hate viagra oral jelly online satisfaction
cenforce stare – zenegra online well brand viagra mix