The Tennessee Voluntary Pre-K program was a very well done study that evaluated the results of Pre-K in Tennessee. There was a control group, and the children were followed and compared until 3rd grade. I was amazed when I read the results of this Voluntary Pre-K (VPK) study, because basically the control group (RCT) did equal to or in some instances better than the VPK children!
I have tried to summarize the results of this study in the next few paragraphs:
The study found that children who participated in VPK experienced considerably greater gains in literacy, language, and math skills during the pre-k year than the control children, and that this difference was recognized as greater preparedness for grade level work by kindergarten teachers at the beginning of the following year.
However, those positive VPK effects on achievement largely disappeared by the end of kindergarten with children in the control group catching up to the VPK participants. Moreover, by second grade the performance of the control children surpassed that of the VPK participants on some achievement measures. This pattern was echoed on the 3rd grade state achievement tests for the full RCT sample. VPK participants scored lower on the reading, math, and science tests than the control children with differences that were statistically significant for math and science.
On other outcomes, including teacher ratings of classroom behavior, retention in grade, disciplinary infractions, and attendance, there were generally few overall differences between VPK participants and control children across the years, although school records did show somewhat more disciplinary actions for the violation of school rules for the VPK participants.
The other question is whether some demographic subgroups of children benefited more from VPK participation than others. Considering the number of combinations of subgroups, outcomes, and school years involved in examining this issue, relatively few differential pre-k effects were found.
I would suggest that everyone reread the last few paragraphs at least once. Wow!
As a bonus I have included the conclusion of the study exactly as it was printed.
Conclusion:
“We are mindful of the limitations of any one study, no matter how well done, and the need for a robust body of research before firm conclusions are drawn. Nonetheless, the inauspicious findings of the current study offer a cautionary tale about expecting too much from state pre-k programs. The fact that the Head Start Impact study – the only other randomized study of a contemporary publicly funded pre-k program – also found few positive effects after the pre-k year adds further cautions (Puma et al., 2012). State-funded pre-k is a popular idea, but for the sake of the children and the promise of pre-k, credible evidence that a rather typical state pre-k program is not accomplishing its goals should provoke some reassessment. It is apparent that the phrase “high-quality pre-k” does not convey enough about what the critical elements of a program should be. Now is the time to pay careful attention to whether the country’s youngest and most vulnerable children are well served in the pre-k classroom environments currently operated and to explore innovations with the potential to serve them better.”
Wow!
Keep in mind that Pre-K is not free! Is Pre-K worth the cost? How much does this program cost California? The short answer is, “a lot!”
In 2015-16 California boosted total spending on Pre-K by $200 million (a 17% increase from the prior year). That put the total spending at greater than $1.4 billion! These increases accounted for more than 1/3 of overall spending increases in the entire U.S.A. for Pre-K. Wow!
So not only does California spend an unbelievable amount on Pre-K, but they also do it inefficiently. Per year, California spends $6409 per child enrolled in Pre-K compared to the national average of $4976. Wow!
So it appears that in this very well done “Tennessee Voluntary Pre-K study”, published in Early Childhood Research Quarterly states that not only is Pre-K is not beneficial for the children, but also in some instances these VPK children appear worse off!
Yikes!
Any chance that California will now re-examine it’s Pre-K policies and spending based on these new facts? Short answer . . . “NO!”, as to me, this freebie is just another way for the Democratic politicians to buy votes!
buy atorvastatin 20mg online cost atorvastatin 40mg order generic lipitor 20mg
ciprofloxacin us – baycip over the counter buy amoxiclav pills
cipro 1000mg drug – buy clavulanate generic buy clavulanate generic
metronidazole 200mg uk – order flagyl 200mg order azithromycin 500mg online
order ciprofloxacin 500 mg online – tindamax 300mg brand erythromycin 500mg over the counter
india ivermectin – axetil tablet buy tetracycline 250mg online
buy valtrex 500mg generic – nemasole tablet order acyclovir 400mg pill
buy acillin generic acillin ca cost amoxicillin
flagyl 200mg cost – order azithromycin 250mg without prescription order zithromax 500mg pill
lasix medication – candesartan 8mg usa buy capoten 25 mg
glycomet 1000mg brand – glucophage 500mg uk lincomycin 500mg cheap
buy generic zidovudine for sale – buy epivir 100 mg without prescription zyloprim 100mg pills
buy clozapine generic – coversum pill buy famotidine without a prescription
seroquel 100mg cheap – order seroquel 100mg sale cheap eskalith without prescription
buy anafranil no prescription – buy cheap generic anafranil doxepin 25mg uk
buy atarax 10mg generic – purchase buspar purchase endep online cheap
order augmentin 375mg online cheap – order linezolid 600mg online buy generic ciprofloxacin 500mg
azithromycin for sale – order tinidazole 500mg pills ciplox online buy
buy generic cleocin – buy cheap generic chloramphenicol buy generic chloromycetin
ivermectin 12 mg tablets – order eryc sale order generic cefaclor
albuterol inhalator medication – order fluticasone without prescription order theophylline 400mg generic
medrol 16mg over the counter – buy fml-forte azelastine 10ml drug
buy clarinex – triamcinolone 10mg drug albuterol canada
buy glyburide online – buy actos 15mg without prescription how to buy dapagliflozin
buy generic glycomet – purchase sitagliptin generic buy generic acarbose
lamisil over the counter – order fulvicin 250mg pills grifulvin v us
order generic semaglutide – purchase semaglutide generic desmopressin generic
buy ketoconazole without prescription – nizoral without prescription itraconazole oral
cost famciclovir 500mg – acyclovir 800mg price order valcivir 1000mg sale
digoxin over the counter – dipyridamole 25mg drug furosemide sale
order lopressor 50mg online – lopressor 100mg price buy adalat 30mg without prescription
order microzide without prescription – order plendil generic order bisoprolol 5mg generic
rosuvastatin pills shower – zetia whilst caduet online dollar
zocor consent – gemfibrozil immediate lipitor belong
dapoxetine delight – viagra plus apparent cialis with dapoxetine surface
cenforce swarm – kamagra pills frown brand viagra stab
brand cialis complex – tadora alley penisole group
cialis soft tabs online traveller – viagra super active online town viagra oral jelly fully
brand cialis sleeve – brand levitra grove penisole merchant
cialis soft tabs online rib – cialis oral jelly broad viagra oral jelly more
cenforce online scream – cenforce online whirl brand viagra pills supreme
dapoxetine obtain – aurogra arise cialis with dapoxetine include