How many times have I said something to the effect that the sun will rise in the west when the very liberal Supreme Court Justices agree with the very conservative Justices in a non-unanimous decision. Sometimes the case is a no-brainer, and as a consequence all nine justices agree. However this past week there was a case that was decided 8-1, and the three far left Justices agreed with the majority opinion by the very conservative Clarence Thomas.
The Supreme Court ruled on 3/8/21 that a student in Georgia could pursue a lawsuit challenging speech restrictions at his college even though he sought only nominal damages.
The 8-1 decision, authored by Justice Clarence Thomas, said that Chike Uzuegbunam — who was silenced by Georgia Gwinnett College officials even after he had obtained a permit to proselytize and handout religious literature — can seek nominal damages despite the fact that the school ultimately changed course and Uzuegbunam subsequently graduated.
Mr. Uzuegbunam sued, saying Gwinnett College’s policies violated his First Amendment rights, and to his credit he did not back down. Supported by the Alliance Defending Freedom, he took his case all the way to SCOTUS.
Justice Clarence Thomas, writing for the majority in the 8-1 decision, said a request for even a token sum, typically a dollar, satisfied the Constitution’s requirement that federal courts decide only actual cases or controversies in cases. The fact that the college had withdrawn the speech code challenged in the suit, he wrote, did not make the case moot.
“Despite being small,” Justice Thomas wrote, “nominal damages are certainly concrete.”
From ABC News:
“When public officials violate constitutional rights, it causes serious harm to the victims,” said Kristen Waggoner, an attorney for Alliance Defending Freedom, which represented Uzuegbunam in the case. ‘When such officials engage in misconduct but face no consequences, it leaves victims without recourse, undermines the nation’s commitment to protecting constitutional rights, and emboldens the government to engage in future violations. We are pleased that the Supreme Court weighed in on the side of justice for those victims.’”
Without going into the details of the case, who do you think was the dissenter? One doesn’t have to think very long to determine that the lone dissenter was Justice John (“we cannot take up any election cases as there will be riots in the streets”) Roberts. He continues to make a case as to why Supreme Court Justices should not be appointed for life. His decisions are all over the lot, and some do not appear to make much sense. On this one the Chief Justice said the majority had turned judges into advice columnists. Huh??? Chief Justice Roberts did not make much sense here . . . again!
Free speech finally wins one, despite Justice Roberts standing for basically nothing.
atorvastatin 80mg for sale lipitor 40mg over the counter atorvastatin 10mg tablet
order generic ciprofloxacin – buy keflex online how to buy augmentin
order cipro generic – buy myambutol 600mg sale buy augmentin 1000mg for sale
order ciprofloxacin 500 mg generic – order amoxicillin 500mg generic
buy erythromycin 250mg online
flagyl ca – buy metronidazole 200mg pill cheap zithromax 500mg
ivermectin 3mg for humans for sale – sumycin drug oral tetracycline 500mg
buy valtrex tablets – valtrex without prescription acyclovir online order
acillin over the counter ampicillin online buy buy generic amoxil
metronidazole for sale – order generic zithromax 250mg cheap azithromycin 250mg
buy furosemide tablets – prograf online buy capoten pills
buy generic glycomet – buy lincomycin 500 mg oral lincomycin 500mg
zidovudine 300mg for sale – buy allopurinol without a prescription
order generic clozaril 100mg – quinapril usa famotidine 20mg pill
seroquel 100mg ca – purchase trazodone buy cheap generic eskalith
buy anafranil tablets – order paxil 20mg pill sinequan generic
buy atarax 25mg sale – order buspar 10mg online cheap endep us
order augmentin for sale – zyvox 600mg tablet ciprofloxacin uk
amoxicillin canada – trimox where to buy order ciprofloxacin 1000mg generic
zithromax 250mg oral – buy generic ofloxacin for sale buy ciplox 500 mg without prescription
where can i buy cleocin – chloramphenicol usa chloromycetin medication
covid and ivermectin – purchase levofloxacin generic order generic cefaclor 250mg
order ventolin without prescription – promethazine buy online order theophylline 400mg without prescription
buy methylprednisolone 4 mg – singulair 10mg tablet order azelastine 10ml sprayer
order clarinex generic – buy generic aristocort 10mg buy albuterol 2mg pills
glyburide 2.5mg uk – order generic glyburide 5mg cheap dapagliflozin 10mg
glucophage 1000mg usa – cheap hyzaar acarbose 25mg ca
cheap prandin 2mg – prandin drug jardiance pills
buy semaglutide 14mg sale – glucovance us buy generic desmopressin online
buy generic terbinafine – purchase fulvicin sale buy grifulvin v tablets
nizoral online order – cost mentax sporanox 100 mg sale
purchase famciclovir for sale – generic valcivir 1000mg oral valaciclovir 500mg
buy lanoxin 250 mg online cheap – order avalide online furosemide 40mg pill
metoprolol sale – order olmesartan 20mg buy nifedipine 30mg without prescription
microzide oral – order hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg pills cost zebeta
nitroglycerin price – nitroglycerin canada valsartan 160mg brand
simvastatin most – zocor invisible atorvastatin queer
crestor tire – zetia buy strain caduet laboratory
viagra professional online pink – buy viagra professional singular levitra oral jelly chief
dapoxetine astonish – dapoxetine radio cialis with dapoxetine separate
cenforce online accurate – cialis no prescription brand viagra careless
brand cialis hammer – apcalis professor penisole equipment
brand cialis clasp – penisole serpent penisole establish
cialis soft tabs belong – cialis super active online fortunate1 viagra oral jelly online swarm
cialis soft tabs intention – viagra oral jelly online your viagra oral jelly online agreeable
dapoxetine until – fildena coal cialis with dapoxetine mill
cenforce race – zenegra pills wife brand viagra stagger
asthma treatment else – inhalers for asthma write asthma medication lurk